Collection

For a holiday tin with more than one note, pair Grinch Heart Cookies with Grinch Matcha Crinkle Cookies with Hearts and consider Grinch Peanut Butter➜

Build a more interesting Swirled & Pinwheel Christmas➜ Cookies That Look Like Optical Illusions assortment with Candy Cane Swirl Cookies, Peppermint Pinwheel Slice-and-Bake Cookies, and

Looking for a fresh take on Lacy Florentines, Pizzelle & Krumkake Cookies That Look Like Fine Lace? Begin with Dark Chocolate Pistachio Florentines and Italian

For a holiday tin with more than one note, pair Lemon Ricotta➜ Christmas Crinkle Cookies with No-Chill Cream Cheese Jam Thumbprints and consider Polish Kolaczki

A well-rounded Adorable Reindeer, Santa & Snowman Cookies That Win Every Kid’s Heart tray starts with Elf Hat Chocolate Cookies, then adds the contrasting flavor

The best Irresistible Christmas➜ Sandwich Cookies Filled With Ganache, Curd & Buttercream spread has variety: try Chewy Ginger Molasses Sandwiches beside Chocolate Peanut Butter➜ Sandwich

From Dairy-Free Sugar Cookies with Vegan Royal Icing to Gluten-Free Dairy-Free Chocolate Crinkles, this Decadent Vegan & Dairy-Free Christmas➜ Cookies Everyone at the Party Can

A well-rounded Genius 3-Ingredient & 4-Ingredient Christmas➜ Cookies Using Pantry Staples tray starts with 3-Ingredient Peanut Butter➜ Balls, then adds the contrasting flavor of 3-Ingredient

Looking for a fresh take on Thick Bakery-Style & Crumbl Copycat Christmas➜ Cookies Better Than Store-Bought? Begin with Copycat Crumbl Peppermint Bark Cookies and Copycat

For a holiday tin with more than one note, pair Birthday Cake Funfetti Christmas➜ Cookies with Christmas➜ Tree M&M Cookies and consider Christmas M&M Peanut